The 3% Rule: Why Most Agents Are Ignoring the Most Profitable Part of Their Database
The platform, the plan, and the people you need
Join a network of agents who are redefining real estate marketing.
Most agents spend their time chasing new business—running ads, knocking on doors, posting on social media—trying to drum up their next listing. But what if the best opportunities weren’t new at all?
The truth is, 3% of the people already in your database will buy or sell in the next 60 to 120 days. The problem? Most agents aren’t paying attention to who they are.
Smart agents aren't just crossing their fingers and waiting for opportunities to land in their lap anymore. They're diving into data, running targeted marketing, and following up like pros to grab the attention of serious sellers way before their competition does.
If you’re relying solely on cold outreach or expensive lead gen to find your next deal, you’re probably working way harder than you need to.
Here’s how you can unlock hidden listings in your own database using the 3% Rule—with a few bonus techniques inspired by top agents and Curaytor Ambassadors Amit Bhuta and Dean Linnell.
Step 1: Identifying the 3%
Most agents have a list of past clients, leads, and contacts sitting in their CRM. Figuring out who's actually thinking about selling, though? That's the tricky part. Here's how you can spot the folks who might be ready to list soon.
- Past clients who bought 5-10 years ago – They’re likely considering a move, even if they haven’t said it out loud yet.
- Homeowners with rising equity – Many sellers don’t realize just how much their home is worth.
- People engaging with your emails and market updates – If someone is opening emails about home values, mortgage rates, or "Just Sold" properties, they’re paying attention for a reason.
- Buyers who never pulled the trigger – Someone who was actively searching for homes six months ago but didn’t buy might need to sell first before they can move forward.
The easiest way to start is by filtering and tagging people in your database who fit these categories.
Pro Tip from Amit Bhuta:
Don’t just rely on automation. Set aside 15–20 minutes each week to manually search for homes that match what your past buyers loved. Make real, thoughtful notes. Then send them a few personalized listings that feel handpicked—not just an MLS drip. It shows you’re paying attention, even if they aren’t ready to move right now.
Why it matters:
This kind of thoughtful, low-pressure follow-up builds loyalty—and keeps your name top of mind when the timing is right.
Step 2: Re-Engage Sellers With the Right Messaging
Once you’ve identified the right people, the next step is to get them talking—without coming across as pushy or salesy.
Here are a few simple outreach ideas:
The Equity Update Email
Subject: What’s your home worth now?
Body: "Home values in [Neighborhood] have changed a lot over the past year. If you’re curious about how much equity you’ve built—and what that means for your next move—I’d be happy to send you an updated valuation. Just reply ‘Yes’ and I’ll put it together for you."
Why it works: It feels natural and low-pressure. You’re not asking them to sell—just giving them useful information.
The “Name Your Price” Email:
Subject: Would you sell your home for the right price?
Body: "Most homeowners aren’t actively looking to sell—but would consider it if the price was right. If you’re curious about what buyers might be willing to pay for your home in today’s market, let’s chat. No pressure, just information."
Why it works: It makes selling feel like an opportunity, not a commitment.
The Just Sold + Market Update Text:
"Hey [Name], I just sold a home near yours in [Neighborhood] for [$XXX,XXX]—much higher than expected. If you’d like to see what your home could sell for, let me know."
Why it works: Social proof. When homeowners see other homes selling for more than expected, they start thinking about their own.
Pro Tip from Dean Linnell:
If it’s a potential seller? You don’t need to push for an immediate meeting. Instead, text something like:
"Hey [Name], just emailed you. A home near yours just hit the market. Smaller kitchen, older bathrooms. Thought you might be interested."
.jpeg)
Step 3: Automate & Scale Your Follow-Ups
If you only reach out once, you’re leaving money on the table. Most people won’t take action immediately—it takes consistent, valuable follow-up to turn interest into listings.
Here’s how to stay in front of sellers without feeling like you’re spamming them:
- Email sequences – Set up automated follow-ups with different angles (market updates, seller success stories, "thinking about selling?" check-ins).
- Retargeting ads – Run digital ads targeting people who have engaged with your emails or visited your home valuation page.
- Personalized video messages – A short, direct video message through email or text feels personal and builds trust faster.
- Handwritten notes – A simple "Hey [Name], I thought of you when I saw this market update. Let me know if you’d like more details!" goes a long way.
Amit Bhuta's Deep Dive Approach:
Instead of asking if someone is "still looking," reference something specific:
"Hey [Name], I just sent you an email. That third home has the white kitchen you loved. Number six has a dual primary bathroom setup—thought of you immediately."
Even if they don’t respond, they see you’re paying attention.
Dean Linnell’s 10–20 Second Video:
For colder leads, record a quick personal video:
"Hey [Name], it’s been a little while. Just thinking about you today. Do you have time to chat this week about your real estate plans? I can flex my schedule for you."
The Agents Who Master This Win More Listings
Most agents are working twice as hard as they need to. They’re chasing new leads, cold calling, and spending money on ads—when the best opportunities are already sitting in their database.
The top agents—the ones who consistently win listings, dominate their market, and get repeat business—are the ones who understand the 3% Rule and work it relentlessly.
The only question is: Are you going to keep ignoring your most profitable leads? Or should you roll up your sleeves and uncover those hidden seller leads you already have?
The easiest way to start? Send a simple Equity Update Email to your past clients today. Your next listing could already be waiting for you.
Key Takeaways
- 3% of your database is ready to move in the next 60-120 days.
- Most agents ignore these leads in favor of chasing new ones.
- A simple email or text can spark the right conversation.
- Consistent follow-up beats random outreach every time.
Expert advice from the best in the Real Estate industry
See how Curaytor can help you elevate your brand and drive real results.
The Real Reason Most Real Estate Agents Struggle to Get Listings
Most agents are stuck in the cycle of chasing cold leads, running ads, and hoping for conversions. But the agents who consistently win more listings have a different approach: they build a brand-first marketing strategy that makes sellers come to them. Instead of lead gen being the first step, it should be the natural result of trust, authority, and consistent presence. This guide explains how to make the shift.
How to build your personal brand to become a locally known expert
This blog recaps a powerful conversation between Curaytor’s Steve Smith and Mindy Jones of the Amy Jones Group on how to build a personal brand that truly connects. Mindy shares how clarity, consistency, and community have shaped her team’s marketing and culture—while showing exactly how she turns values into action. If you want to build a brand that earns trust, grows your business, and actually feels like you, this is a must-read.
From Listings to Loyalty: How Damian Hall Is Using AI, Video, and Storytelling to Dominate the Luxury Market
Luxury real estate agent Damian Hall shares how he’s using AI, video, and storytelling to market smarter—not harder—in today’s competitive market. From scaling across multiple markets to prepping full marketing packages in under an hour, this blog breaks down the exact tools and strategies he’s using right now. If you’re looking to future-proof your business and stand out in 2025, this is your blueprint.